Beauty Booty: Secret Clinical Strength Deodorant

by Rachel on 01/07/2010

I hate shopping for deodorant/antiperspirant. That aisle makes my head explode. There are so many options, so many fragrances, and I do not have a point of reference for what I need. I usually pick a brand I think I like — I can never seem to remember what the last one I used was — and then pick a label that sounds useful — “invisible solid”…hmm, OK, why not? — and just hope for best. And it’s never a huge issue because I am one of the least sweaty people I know. Sometimes I don’t particularly like what I’ve bought — one in particular always felt slimy by day’s end — but I can never seem to remember what works and what doesn’t when I’m faced with all those options.

Recently, a bunch of deodorant companies came out with their new “Prescription Strength” super-duper deodorant. I wasn’t entirely sure why I needed it, but I just kept seeing it in ads, so I wanted to try it. Except, depending on the store, it costs $8- 10! Given that I’m the kind of person who can forget to apply it and still have people willing to sit next to me on the bus, I couldn’t justify it. But when I ran out of my old stuff…and had a Rite Aid gift card…I knew the time was right!

Of course, I was still faced with the brand and scent issue. (It is “scent” by the way…not “flavor.” I used to work at Bath & Body Works and when customers would ask about “flavors,” I just wanted to ask them how it tasted.) I had to narrow things down. First, I decided against Dove, because I really don’t like their deodorant too much (I’ve tried it like ten times because I always think it’s going to feel all lovely and natural…it always just makes my skin itch and it’s gross and dry and crumbly). I think I generally buy Secret, so I went with that. Then I had to select a type from the four options: Waterproof, Sport, Sensitive Skin, and Original. The ingredients were the same on each. I’ll admit, Sport was tempting. I mean, the only time I work up a sweat is when I’m working out, and the word “Sport” made me think I was an athlete. But the words “Marathon Fresh Scent,” were a huge turn-off. First, there’s nothing fresh about a marathon scent, as far as I can tell. And second, I was afraid it would smell disgusting, in an effort to make beefy, burly women smell like girlie-girls. I’m putting this on my shaven underarm, thank you very much! Ugh…nope, couldn’t do it. Waterproof seemed silly, as I never get wet, and all deodorant/antiperspirant is like…sweat-proof. And I don’t have sensitive skin. So…Original. “Powder Protection Scent.” How…unoriginal.

Still, I was so excited to use it, after seeing it in all my magazines. I wanted to get really sweaty, like just drenched, and walk into the locker room basically in a puddle of my own sweat, and lift my arm, and there I’d show all the other women around me my miraculously Sahara-esque pits and dry shirt.

So it comes in a pretty big box…I’d say about seven or eight inches. When I got home and opened the box, I was shocked that the actual deodorant is only four inches tall. Whaaaaaaa? I felt like I had just gone home with a black guy and then, like, mid-makeout, he’s saying, “Oh, by the way, my dad’s white.” It really looks like it’s going to be bigger.

But oh well. I had paid my $10. There was no turning back!

Now, again, I’m a very un-perspiring person. I rarely “drip sweat” like the Ying Yang Twins rap about girls doing. I don’t ever check myself for fear of wet spots. I don’t really sweat unless I’m in the gym or I’m playing sports in the deep south on the hottest day of the summer. I’m not saying this to make you think I’m special; I simply want you to know that this is the review of a kinda sweatless girl.

Well, I have to say, after using the Secret Clinical for a week….it is different than the others. And it is good!!

I actually notice the biggest difference not when I’m working out, but when I’m just going about my daily activities. I just feel so dry. It’s like, before, even with my lack of much sweat, at the end of the day, I still would re-apply if I were going to go out. You just get that little bit of less-than-fresh dampness. However, that is not the case with the new Secret! It dries and then you are just dry from there on out. I’m amazed! When you do start to sweat, it’s not like you can smell it “come on” and start working, something that really bothers me. It doesn’t smell too deodoranty; it’s just clean..it smells like a girl should smell!

So, despite the higher price tag and the totally misleading packaging, I’m actually going to keep buying this! I’m excited about my newly found extra-dryness and really happy that the trip down that aisle just got that much easier.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

amanda January 7, 2010 at 8:19 AM

I use Secret Clinical Strength deodorant from the first time it came out. I am a sweaty girl sometimes (basically hormonal for me) even when I am not working out. This has been the closest one to help me combat my problems. By the way, I also agree on your accessment of Dove. Dove’s deodorant products suck!! Also the Sport version does smell nice! :)
.-= amanda´s last blog ..The Biggest Loser is Bad for Our Nation’s Health =-.

Joanna Sutter January 7, 2010 at 8:28 AM

Ok, but does it still leave white marks on your shirts? Some of those “invisible” claims are just flat out lies! End rant.
.-= Joanna Sutter´s last blog ..David and Joanna =-.

Stacy January 7, 2010 at 9:44 AM

I have been using Secret Clinical strength for a while and like you, not because I am a super sweaty person but because I just thought I would try it and see what the hype was all about. I really like it. I recently ran out and used another brand that I had at the house. ICK! You can totally tell the difference. Glad you found something that you like even though it should be as big as the box.

Sheri January 7, 2010 at 11:04 AM

I like this one too except there always seemed to be a film of deoderant on the area which made it difficult to shave. Anyone else find this to be true and if so, how did you get past it?
.-= Sheri´s last blog ..My New Year’s Goals =-.

Tracy January 7, 2010 at 11:05 AM

Yes I use this too and love it!! It’s all I use now!

One tip to avoid the high price tag tho…check for it at Target or Meijer…they’re usually a little cheaper there at around $7!

thedelishdish January 7, 2010 at 11:20 AM

i love this post…youre too funny! ive been using this since it came out and loove it (and unlike you i actually really need it) and def notice a difference compared to other deodorants!

Lily @ Lily's Health Pad January 7, 2010 at 3:23 PM

I’ve been wanting to try this stuff! I sweat a lot when I exercise, so I think I may need to start shelling out the 8 bucks. Thanks for the review.

Rachel January 7, 2010 at 8:01 PM

Joanna — In my experience, all deodorant leaves white marks so I just try to be extra careful when I’m putting on my shirt…sooo I can’t really answer that!

Becca January 7, 2010 at 8:35 PM

I really wish I had had this when I Studied Abroad!!! I’m usually not a sweaty girl in an every day setting, but sight-seeing in 80+ degree weather brought out the worst in me! I brought a travel size deodorant with me as we were staying in Verona for four weeks, and why not make room in my bag by buying all my toiletries in the grocery story? It worked out except for the fact that they don’t have deodorant, just antiperspirant, so if you sweat through it, you smell like a European (or Turk, same thing), nasty. Just a cautionary tale for any of you travelers!!!

Alexa March 8, 2010 at 8:40 PM

I just got the “marathon fresh scent” variety. Smells like my dad’s cologne.

Rachel March 8, 2010 at 8:41 PM

Well thank you for sharing. That sounds absolutely nasty!

JM August 23, 2011 at 11:07 AM

This is the only product that keeps me dry all day, even through hot summers in Phoenix. After switching to Secret Clinical Strength from Degree, I am able to go without a blouse underneath my business jackets – it is that good!

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: